Ryan Faulk two years ago published another Holocaust denying piece. Now he tries to "prove" according to American Jewish Year Book (AJYB) world Jewish population was 15.7 million in 1939 and 14.5 million decades later and it couldn't grow after the war due to low total fertility rate (TFR).
It should be noted TFR below 2.1 doesn't automatically mean more deaths than births. Percentage of women of reproductive age and increasing life expectancy are other crucial factors. Population can have positive natural increase even for decades of TFR being less than 2.1. TFR of Canada fell below the replacement level over 50 years ago, but annual death rate still didn't surpass annual birth rate.
Faulk argues Jewish community in the United States experienced significant negative natural population change. He claims immigration of over 1.5 million Jews after the war is the only way how to explain post-war increase of American Jewish population by 1 million.
Even Walter Sanning, after analyzing age structure of American Jews in 1970, acknowledged American Jewry had in 1946-1970 excess of births over deaths 865,000! He also suggested much lower immigration figure - 495,000 (Walter Sanning, The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry, pp. 159-162).
But what serious researchers? In Papers in Jewish Demography 1977, an anthology edited by U. O. Schmelz and Sergio DellaPergola, you can find Ira Rosenwaike's article A Synthetic Estimate of American Jewish Population Movement over the Last Three Decades. I am really grateful to Prof. Sergio DellaPergola for sending me Rosenwaike's paper.
The author calculated between 1940 and 1970 American Jewish population increased by 1.35 million - by 1,028,000 due to natural increase and 322,000 thanks to immigration. Yes, Jewish birth rate, despite being by 22-23 percent lower than the one of general population, led to annual natural growth almost 1 percent in 1946-1957! We talk about the baby boom time, when total American birth rate was ~2.5 percent per a year.
Note: Rosenwaike questioned reliability of pre-war 1937 study, which reckoned 4.77 million Jews lived in the United States, and relied rather on a March 1957 Current Population Survey, which found 5,050,000 Jews twenty years later. Another two post-war surveys - 1948 and 1970 - counted 4.5 million and 5,480,000 (adjusted to not exclude 110,000 Jewish persons living in group quarters) Jews in the United States respectively, adding up Rosenwaike's model.
After official governmental data abandoned classification 'Hebrew' among the ethnic rubrics, statistics and estimates developed by immigrant Jewish aid organizations became the main source of knowledge concerning Jewish migration to the United States (Ira Rosenwaike, 'A Synthetic Estimate of American Jewish Population Movement over the Last Three Decades', in: Usiel Oskar Schmelz and Sergio DellaPergolla (eds.), Papers in Jewish Demography 1977, pp. 83-102).
(ibid, pp. 95-97)
If the 1937 study had been accurate, expectable American Jewish population would have been closer to 6.5 million in 1970.
AJBY's figures for American Jewish population in the 1960s and the 1970s were a composite of individual community estimates. The figure 6,059,000 from 1972 cited by Faulk (5,870,000 in 1970) was too high because by 1973 there was no recent estimate for Jewish population in New York, which during the 1960s and 1970s, due to emigration to cities like Los Angels and Miami, significantly declined. After AJYB received results of a new survey conducted in the city, its estimate of total American Jewish population decreased to 5.75 million. In addition, by 1980 most of the community estimates, in fact, included also non-Jews living in households with at least one Jew, mostly non-Jewish spouses (Alvin Chenkin, 'Demographic', in: American Jewish Year Book, 176, Vol. 76, p. 229; Deborah Dash Moore, Jewish New York, p. 305; Alvin Chenkin, 'Demographic', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1981, Vol. 81, p. 170).
Sergio DellaPergola calculated 5,520,000 Jews lived in the United States in 1970 and 5,650,000 in 1980, by 350,000 and 270,000 respectively less than according to flawed AJBY's original estimates (Sergio DellaPergola, World Jewish Population, 2024, p. 41; Leon Shapiro, 'World Jewish Population', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1971, Vol. 72, p. 477; Leon Shapiro, 'World Jewish Population', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1981, Vol. 81, p. 286).
Besides the United States, the other destinations where European Jews went were Latin America, Canada, South Africa, Australia and, of course, Israel. Number of those who permanently settled in the rest of the world - most of Africa and Asia outside Israel - was negligible (1,000s at most).
Jews of Argentina numbered 286,000 in 1970. Heavily inflated figure 500,000 cited by the 1968-1972 volumes of AJYB, was disproven by demographers who studied results of the 1960 census and contemporary vital statistics. Significant Jewish immigration to Argentina basically ended on the eve of the war. During the 1940s, the 1950s and the 1960s by 18,200 more Jews emigrated than immigrated (Sergio DellaPergola and Usiel Oskar Schmelz, 'The Demography of Latin American Jewry', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1985, Vol. 85, pp. 56-66). Sanning implied post-war Jewish immigration 150,000 for the whole Latin America, 90,000 for Argentina, too high by 108,000 (Sanning, Dissolution, pp. 168-169).
Net immigration of Canadian Jewry was 2,176 in 1931-1941 and 43,687 in 1941-1961, excess of births over deaths 11,339 and 40,176 respectively (Louis Rosenberg, 'Canada', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1963, Vol. 64, p. 261). Roughly 30,000 Jews came to Canada in 1961-1971 (Ivor I. Millman, 'Data on Diaspora Jewish Populations from Official Censuses', in: Usiel Oskar Schmelz, Paul Glikson and S. J. Gould (eds.), Studies in Jewish Demography: Survey for 1972-1980, p. 54).
South Africa had 118,000 Jews in 1970 and 90,000 in 1936. Taking into account average annual natural increase 0.5 percent typical for this diaspora during the period under review, there were probably ~10,500 newcomers in 1936-1970 (Sergio DellaPergola and Allie A. Dubb, 'South African Jewry: A Sociodemographic Profile', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1988, Vol. 88, pp. 64-69).
Jewish community in Australia doubled to 65,000 in 1970 (DellaPergola, World Jewish Population, 2024, p. 25) compared with 33,000 three decades earlier.
On the 15th May 1948 650,000 Jews inhabited British Mandate of Palestine (Sergio DellaPergola, Uzi Rebhun and Mark Tolts, 'Prospecting the Jewish Future: Population Projections, 2000-2080', in: American Jewish Year Book, 2000, Vol. 100, p. 108), compared to 411,000 at the end of 1938. Average Jewish annual natural increase was 1.78 percent in the first half of the 1940s (A Survey of Palestine: Volume I., pp. 141-144). So the upward change can be explained by excess of births over deaths 88,000 and immigration 151,000.
Israel in 1948-1971 admitted 601,177 European Jews and 55,000 Turkish Jews (Statistical Abstract of Israel 2013, Table 4.4). As I mentioned in my previous post, these statistics divided Olim by country of birth, not by the last country of residence, so the sum includes also European-born Olim from Americas, Australia and South Africa.
Because the migration statistics above refer to net migration (excess of immigration over emigration) rather than immigration in case of the United States, Canada by 1961, Argentina, South Africa and Australia, we Olim born in these areas, so 45,000 (the vast majority of foreign-born Jews living there were of European origin), should be added aswell (Abstract, Table 4.4).
Note: In other hand, for example emigration of 2,000 Jews from South Africa to Australia is no problem because it in exchange makes European Jewish immigration to Australia lower by 2,000.
At the beginning of 1970 3,486,000 Jews remained in Europe and Asian regions of the Soviet Union and Turkey (DellaPergola, Rebhun and Tolts, 'Jewish Future', p. 108). Among them North African Jews who entered France in the 1960s and a certain number of Israelis.
Israel immigration rate was by 225,000 higher than net migration in 1945-1969. Out of 184,000 Jews who in 1948-1967 left Israel 93 percent moved to Europe, Turkey, the Americas, South Africa and Australia. Most of the remaining 7 percent were North African and Iranian Jews who returned to their country of origin (DellaPergola, Rebhun and Tolts, 'Jewish Future', p. 106; Ori Yehudai, Leaving Zion, pp. 18-19).
After the war Soviet Jews still had some excess of births over deaths, more exactly 143,000 by the 1959 census (Mark Kupovetsky, 'Jewish Population Losses during World War II within the Prewar and Postwar Borders of the USSR', in: Alfred Kokh and Pavel Polian (eds.), Denial of the Denial, or the Battle of Auschwitz, pp. 158-159). Then natural population decline started. By the next census in 1970 Jewish population decreased by 117,000. Between the two censuses 12,000 Soviet Jews emigrated to Israel, so excess of deaths over births wasn't more than 105,000 in 1959-1969.
AJYB's estimates of Soviet Jewish population in the 1960s and 1970s can be ignored as 100 percent fictitious. AJYB simply took results of the 1959 census and erroneously assumed Soviet Jewry had the same rate of natural population growth as general Soviet population, so they overestimated size of Soviet Jewry by 469,000 in 1970, three quarters of a million in 1975 and 850,000 in 1979 (Shapiro, 'World Jewish Population', 1971, p. 476; DellaPergola, Rebhun and Tolts, 'Jewish Future', p. 108; Usiel Oskar Schmelz, 'Evolution and Projection of World Jewish Population', in: Usiel Oskar Schmelz, Paul Glikson and S. J. Gould (eds.), Studies in Jewish Demography: Survey for 1972-1980, p. 8).
French Jewish population tripled from post-war 180,000 to 530,000 in 1970, mostly thanks to the influx of 235,000 North African Jews and total excess of births over deaths 68,000 (Sergio DellaPergola, 'A New Estimate of Greater Paris Jewish Population Size', in: Usiel Oskar Schmelz, Paul Glikson and S. J. Gould (eds.), Studies in Jewish Demography: Survey for 1972-1980, p. 24).
Jews of the United Kingdom, after high annual natural increase 1.1 percent at the start of the 1950s, by 1970 fell into negative balance of births and deaths -0.3 percent per a year. Initial high birth rate still allowed natural population growth 37,250 with population 350,000 and 395,000 in 1945 and 1970 respectively (Sergio DellaPergola, 'Jews in the European Community: Sociodemographic Trends and Challenges', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1993, Vol. 93, p. 75).
Three largest post-war European Jewish communities - Soviet, French and British - produced in 1945-1970 excess of births over deaths ~143,250. In addition, Jews remaining in Poland, at least during the first post-war years, experienced decent birth rate over 2 percent annualy (H. S. Halevi, 'The Demography of Jewish Communities in Eastern Europe', in: The Jewish Journal of Sociology, 1960, Vol. 2, Nr. 1, p. 108). Not to mention births in displaced persons camps. Lets be generous and say Jews in the rest of Europe suffered natural population decline so large it averaged out natural increase of European Jewry as the whole to zero.
Lets summarize the calculation above. European Jewish population at the start of 1970 (3,486,000) plus European Jewish immigrants to Palestine/Israel in 1939-1971 minus European immigrants in 1970-1971 (818,000) plus total Jewish immigration to the United States (322,000), Canada (74,500), Latin America (42,000), South Africa (10,500) and Australia (32,000) minus North African Jews who went to France (235,000) and Israelis who made yerida to the relevant areas (225,000x0.93).
Including those who fled Europe during the war, ~4,341,000 European Jews survived.
The Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry determined 9,946,200 Jews were in Europe on the eve of the war. This number needs to be revised by adding Turkey (~77,000 Jews) and replacing USSR+Baltics estimate by more realistic 3,326,300 - 246,300 Baltics, 3,080,000 old Soviet territories after taking into account 1939-1941 natural increase (Kupovetsky, 'Jewish Population Losses', pp. 154-157). In case of Poland Joseph Marcus, author of detailed work Social and Political History of the Jews in Poland, 1919-1939, concluded at least 3,460,000 Jews were living in Poland at the outbreak of the war (Joseph Marcus, Social and Political History of the Jews in Poland, 1919-1939, p. 173).
With pre-war population ~9,898,500 and ~4,341,000 survivors, Jewish death toll during the war amounts to ~5,557,500.
Faulk complains before the war AJYB stated only 15.7 million Jews lived in the world and insists that higher figures were adopted just after the war. The 1939-1940 volume of AJYB, ignored by him, reported 16,180,000 Jews were in the world. The volume still cointains several outdated statistics, for example Jewish population according to the 1926 Soviet census, not taking into account the 1939 census. It estimated 9,562,000 Jews lived in Europe (including Asian parts of the Soviet Union and Turkey). This post calculated number by 336,500 higher, increasing pre-war world Jewish population to 16,516,500. The 1946-1947 volume of AJYB reported 11,123,800 Jews remained ('Jewish Population of the World', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1939-1940, Vol. 41, pp. 583-587; 'Jewish Population', in: American Jewish Year Book, 1946-1947, Vol. 48, p. 603).
Eventual modification of the pre-war and post-war figure to fit Rosenwaike, who believed 4,162,000 Jews lived in the United States before the war and 4,359,000 after rather than 4,831,000 and 5,000,000 respectively, changes nothing because it reduces both pre-war and post-war number to 15,847,500 and 10,475,800 respectively.
(DellaPergola, World Jewish Population, 2024, p. 3)
Faulk's whining about DellaPergola revising AJBY's estimates of Jewish population in the 1960s and the 1970s, allegedly ad hoc to "save the Holocaust narrative", is meaningless aswell. The revisions were fully justified, as it was demonstrated above in case of the Soviet Union, the United States and Argentina. These three countries accounted for the vast majority of the changes - 1 million out of 1.2 million in 1970 and 1.2 million out of 1.5 million in 1980.
Faulk is also wrong about post-war Jewish birth rate. Natural increase allowed Jewish population outside Europe to grow by over 2 million in 1940-1970 - by 1,028,000 in the United States, by +800,000 in Israel (763,000 in 1945-1970: DellaPergola, Rebhun and Tolts, 'Jewish Future', p. 106), by +100,000 in Canada, Latin America and South Africa and by several 100,000s in North Africa and Asia without Turkey, the USSR and Israel (only in Morocco by 75,500).
In a nutshell:
- World Jewish population after the war produced birth rate high enough to reach figure calculated by Sergio DellaPergola for 1970 after dropping during the war to not more than 11 million due to the Holocaust.
- American Jewry didn't experience natural population decline in 1940-1975 and most of increase during this time period came from excess of births over deaths rather than immigration.
- Faulk's clinging to AJYB's original estimates of Jewish population in the 1960s and 1970s is absurd. Sergio DellaPergola's revisions were fully justified, as can be seen especially in case of the Soviet Union, Argentina and the United States.
- Already the 1939/1940 volume of AJYB already reported World Jewish population exceeded 16 million - despite still adopting some significantly outdated figures.
- Post-war migration can't explain drastic decrease of European Jewish population.
- Calculated Jewish population drop during the war adds up standard estimates of Holocaust death toll.


