Thursday, November 19, 2026

Tales of Junk Demography: Ryan Faulk's Substack Article The Jewish Population Miracle Debunked

Ryan Faulk two years ago published another Holocaust denying piece. Now he tries to "prove" according to American Jewish Year Book (AJYB) world Jewish population was 15.7 million in 1939 and 14.5 million decades later and it couldn't grow after the war due to low total fertility rate (TFR).

It should be noted TFR below 2.1 doesn't automatically mean more deaths than births. Percentage of women of reproductive age and increasing life expectancy are other crucial factors. Population can have positive natural increase even for decades of TFR being less than 2.1. TFR of Canada fell below the replacement level over 50 years ago, but annual death rate still didn't surpass annual birth rate.

Faulk argues Jewish community in the United States experienced significant negative natural population change. He claims immigration of over 1.5 million Jews after the war is the only way how to explain post-war increase of American Jewish population by 1 million.

Even Walter Sanning, after analyzing age structure of American Jews in 1970, acknowledged American Jewry had in 1946-1970 excess of births over deaths 865,000! He also suggested much lower immigration figure - 495,000 (Walter Sanning, The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry, pp. 159-162).

But what serious researchers? In Papers in Jewish Demography 1977, an anthology edited by U. O. Schmelz and Sergio DellaPergola, you can find Ira Rosenwaike's article A Synthetic Estimate of American Jewish Population Movement over the Last Three Decades. I am really grateful to Prof. Sergio DellaPergola for sending me Rosenwaike's paper.

Monday, June 29, 2026

Conclusion: 3 pillars

Three documents. Three pillars. One structure holding all of it up.

The first pillar is the claim that multiple-corpse cremation was physically impossible. This is the foundation everything else rests on, and it is the one Mattogno cannot keep stable. In 2010 it was absolute: even two bodies in one muffle would block the openings. By 2015, with Fritz Sander’s account of Topf furnaces being routinely overloaded sitting in front of him, the impossibility narrowed to three bodies, with two left unmentioned. A genuine physical limit does not move between editions. The muffle dimensions are the same in both years. What moved was the argument, retreating exactly as far as the evidence forced it to.

Wednesday, June 24, 2026

Multiple Corpse Cremation part 2: the Sander Memorandum

Mattogno’s position on multiple-corpse cremation is stated in absolute terms in Auschwitz: The Case for Sanity (2010):

“Therefore, even if multiple cremations had been possible in the ovens of Auschwitz-Birkenau, they would not have led to any gain in time or in fuel. I stress the words ‘if multiple cremations had been possible,’ because the design of the triple-muffle and 8-muffle ovens did not allow multiple cremations… Actually, if two or three bodies had been introduced into one muffle, the corpses would have blocked the three openings.” (p. 285)

The claim is absolute. Even two corpses were physically impossible.

Sunday, June 21, 2026

Multiple Corpse Cremation part 1: The October 1941 Planning Document


The October 1941 planning document for Krematorium II is the first document we’ll examine explicitly mentioning multiple corpse cremation and unfortunately for Mattogno it’s not looking good for his case for “sanity”.

The Auschwitz construction office recorded:

“Auxiliary operations: Due to the large occupancy (125,000 prisoners) a crematorium will be erected. It contains 5 muffle furnaces with 3 muffles each for 2 men, so that 60 men can be cremated in one hour.” (Bartosik, Martyniak & Setkiewicz, The Origins of the Birkenau Camp, Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum, 2017, p. 170.)

Five furnaces. Three muffles each. Fifteen muffles total. Two bodies per muffle. Sixty bodies per hour. The arithmetic is unambiguous, and it appears in an official planning document without qualification or caveat.

Friday, June 19, 2026

The Bischoff Memorandum

On 28 June 1943, SS-Untersturmführer Josef Janisch prepared a document for the signature of SS-Sturmbannführer Karl Bischoff this document was to be sent to SS-Brigadeführer Hans Kammler reporting the completed cremation capacity of all five Auschwitz crematoria:

“1.) Old Crematorium I  3×2 muffle furnaces 340 persons 
2.) New Krematorium II 5×3 muffle furnaces  1,440 persons 
3.) New Krematorium III 5×3 muffle furnaces 1,440 persons 
4.) New Krematorium IV 8 muffle furnaces 768 persons 
5.) New Krematorium V 8 muffle furnaces 768 persons 
Total for 24-hour operation: 4,756 persons.”

Wednesday, June 17, 2026

Missing Documents and the Wrong Suspect

Before reaching the single most important memorandum on cremation capacity at Auschwitz, there is a preliminary issue worth examining because it reveals a great deal about Mattogno’s overall method.

Mattogno has repeatedly claimed to have examined all 88,200 pages of the Auschwitz construction archives held in Moscow. He is very proud of this fact. Yet from those 88,200 pages, almost no documentation recording actual individual cremations survives. After denier critic John Zimmerman pointed out this rather obvious problem, Mattogno eventually produced what appears to be the only document related to an individual cremation in the entire archive: a 1940 test cremation entirely unrelated to the Birkenau crematoria under discussion.

This absence matters enormously, though not for the reason Mattogno would prefer.

We are dealing with one of the largest cremation facilities in Europe, operating continuously during the height of the war. Sparse day-to-day operational documentation is not a neutral historical fact. It is suspicious in itself, and the most immediate question it raises is why. Rudolf Höss, Henryk Tauber, Perry Broad, and others testified that records were systematically destroyed as the war ended. Mattogno, however, shifts attention away from the people with the clearest motive to destroy those records and instead attributes the gap to Soviet archival selection (discussed further in part 5). He acknowledges the documentary absence while attributing it to Soviet archival selection, despite presenting no direct evidence for such intervention.

The rhetorical convenience of this move is worth noting. When surviving German documents support Mattogno’s conclusions, they are reliable and authoritative. When they undermine his conclusions, Soviet tampering becomes plausible. When documents are missing, the implication is that Soviet archivists removed material favourable to the defence rather than that the SS destroyed incriminating records during the collapse of the Reich. Every possible evidentiary outcome is made to support the conclusion Mattogno already wanted to reach. That is not scepticism. It is special pleading: the standards of evidence change depending on which conclusion needs to be defended.

This pattern repeats constantly throughout his work.


Changelog: not directly relevant reference removed 18/6/2026

Tuesday, June 16, 2026

Carlo Mattogno, Auschwitz Cremation, and the Problem of Selective Scepticism

Holocaust denial tends to focus most of its attention on the gas chambers. That is the emotional centre of the debate and naturally where both sides spend most of their energy. But there is another issue sitting right beside it that denial literature cannot avoid: body disposal. More specifically, could Auschwitz-Birkenau cremate the number of bodies historians say it did?

This is where Carlo Mattogno enters the picture.

Among Holocaust deniers, Mattogno occupies an almost untouchable position. He is treated not as merely one writer among many but as the movement’s leading technical authority on Auschwitz. Germar Rudolf writes in Auschwitz Lies that anyone who wants to seriously challenge Holocaust denial “needs to focus on the many papers and monographs written by Carlo Mattogno,”  whose knowledge of the Holocaust: “may be second to none and that not only includes revisionists but possibly also all the orthodox historians worldwide.” (p.210)

That is a remarkable claim, and it creates a remarkable burden. If Mattogno really is the strongest researcher Holocaust denial can produce, then his work should withstand close scrutiny. His arguments should be internally consistent, methodologically sound, and capable of surviving direct comparison with the documentary record.

What one finds when reading Mattogno carefully is something quite different. His conclusion shift whenever the evidence becomes inconvenient. German wartime documents are treated as unimpeachable when they support his position and suddenly unreliable, manipulated, or misunderstood by everyone but him when they do not. Impossibilities slyly become possible if a document needs handwaving. Technical discussions routinely expand outward in every direction except the one that matters most: what the documents themselves actually say.

Mattogno has effectively made cremation his life’s work. Since the 1990s he has written thousands of pages on cremation capacity, fuel consumption, refractory wear, furnace throughput, and corpse disposal at Auschwitz. There is no question he has invested enormous time in the subject. But page count is not evidence, and technical vocabulary is not historical method.

Mattogno himself appears deeply aware of his page count. In The “Extermination Camps” of “Aktion Reinhardt” he writes: 
“In fact, I am the author ‘most damaging’ to their books about Auschwitz, which I exhaustively refuted in the more than 700 pages of my already quoted study Auschwitz: The Case for Sanity.” (2013 ed, p. 1496)
The emphasis on quantity over quality is revealing because it reflects the way Mattogno argues generally. The objective often appears to be less about establishing a point clearly than about surrounding the reader with technicality, calculations, diagrams, block quotations, and side discussions until the reader assumes there must be something persuasive hidden beneath the mass of detail. This approach works surprisingly well on audiences unfamiliar with the primary sources. A 700-page technical study creates an immediate impression of authority. Most readers are not going to check every citation, verify every quotation, or test whether the arguments actually follow from the evidence presented.

That is one reason Mattogno’s work deserves close scrutiny.

This series will not follow him into every secondary theatre of argument. It will not spend pages debating abstract combustion models or calculations detached from the documentary evidence. That terrain favours confusion over clarity and allows weak arguments to survive by burying them beneath technical detail. Instead, this article will focus on a much simpler question: what do the documents actually say? What did the people designing, operating, and discussing these crematoria say they were doing? And how does Mattogno respond when those documents contradict him? And what does this reveal about the methodology of denials greatest researcher on the topic he seems to consider most important? 

Once one strips away the technical clutter, a very consistent pattern emerges.

Monday, June 08, 2026

"Then the vehicle drives on for another 10 minutes, and by the time they reach the execution site, the occupants arrive already dead".

The Wehrmacht researcher Sergey Vershinin is currently publishing excerpts from the diary of Johannes Gutschmidt. Gutschmidt (1876-1961) was the commandant of various POW camps. Specifically the topic under the discussion was his time in Smolensk where he was the commandant of the Dulag-231.

In his diary Gutschmidt twice mentions a visit to the building of the Smolensk NKVD, or, more specifically, to the execution cellar where people used to be shot.

He attaches some valuable photos of the cellar. The second visit was on 07.04.1942:

7.4.42. Ganz früh rief mich Oberst Marschall an, ich sollte sofort das Nordlager auf Ausbaumöglichkeit erkunden. Ich fuhr mit Janusch um 8 ab und es zeigte sich, dass das Lager nicht zu gebrauchen ist. Der Oberst kam auch noch heraus und stimmte mir zu. Auf der Rückfahrt besichtigten wir die Hinrichtungszelle und die GPU Gefängniszellen, die jetzt von der Sicherungspolizei belegt sind. In jeder Zelle sassen 4 bis 6 Personen. Bei uns [handgeschrieben: i. e. bei der geheimen Feldpolizei] werden die Leute ebenfalls durch Pistolenschüsse ins Genick erschossen oder sie werden mit einem Gasauto heraus geschafft. Das hält vor der Stadt und schaltet die Auspuffgase so um, dass sie in das Innere des Wagens gelangen. Dann fährt der Wagen noch 10 Minuten weiter und an der Hinrichtungsstelle kommen die Insassen schon tot an und werden sofort in die Gruben geworfen. Nachmittags machte ich in der Hinrichtungszelle einige Aufnahmen mit Böhms Sonne.

7.4.42. Very early, Colonel Marschall called me; I was to immediately scout the North Camp for expansion possibilities. I left with Janusch at 8, and it turned out that the camp is of no use. The Colonel also came out later and agreed with me. On the return trip, we inspected the execution cell and the GPU prison cells, which are now occupied by the Security Police. In each cell 4 to 6 people used to sit. With us [handwritten: i. e. with the secret field police], people are likewise executed by pistol shots to the back of the neck, or they are transported away in a gas car (Gasauto). It stops outside the city and redirects the exhaust gases in such a way that they enter the interior of the vehicle. Then the vehicle drives on for another 10 minutes, and by the time they reach the execution site, the occupants arrive already dead and are immediately thrown into the pits. In the afternoon, I took some photos in the execution cell using a "Böhm's Sun".

The archival source provided by Vershinin is BArch MSG 2/10902, Bl. 209.


The question of the authenticity of the diary (i.e. whether the text is contemporaneous to the events it describes or whether it's a memoir in form of a diary) was analyzed by Christian Hartmann in this article. As he points out, retroactively faking 450 double-sided, detail-filled sheets for an incomprehesible purpose is simply implausible (there are also other arguments). What cannot be entirely excluded, however, is that the diary could have been retyped after 1945. The forensic testing of the materials showed them to have been available throughout the 1940s.This means that in theory some passages could have been deleted or added during the retyping.

That said, the purpose of adding a passage like this after the war eludes me. It would be incriminating, if anything. It also fits with the gas vans having arrived in Smolensk just a couple of months prior to this entry.

Tuesday, June 02, 2026

Tales of Junk Demography: How Sanning Invented 100,000 European Jews in Morocco

In Chapter Seven dealing with post-war Jewish migration, Sanning tries to convince his readers that part of the Oriental Jews who came to Israel during the first two decades after its declaration of independence were, in fact, European Jews. Among them, allegedly 100,000 out of 252,642 Moroccan olims.

To support his assertion, he cited the results of 1936 French Moroccan census, which found 161,000 Jews, then implied a natural increase of 1 percent per a year and stated Moroccan Jewish population was 50,000 in 1970. This would allow the native Moroccan Jewish community to give Israel only 150,000 new souls, by 100,000 less than actually arrived. The self-appointed revisionist demographer concluded the only explanation is the mass resettlement of 100,000 European Jews in Moroccan territory during the war or shortly after (Walter Sanning, The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry, p. 164).

Note: In the case of France, Sanning assumed totally 170,000 North African Jewish newcomers, 110,000 from Algeria and 60,000 from Tunisia (ibid., p. 169).

Sanning's calculation is, of course, wrong.

Friday, May 29, 2026

Tales of Junk Demography: An Introduction

 Over 17 years ago Jonathan Harisson finished his series The Crazy World of Walter Sanning criticizing The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry, the 1980s "revisionist" attempt of study of Jewish demography.

Sanning is still taken seriously by many Holocaust deniers. Deanna Spingola heavily refered to The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry in The Ruling Elite: Death, Destruction, and Domination published in 2014. Don't forget about Ryan Faulk. Or X Nazi star Karl Radl.