On Jonnie Hargis's Führerbunker, Canadian Holocaust denier Friedrich Braun posted "Ninety-Five Theses on the Holocaust" by Professor Patrick McNally of the Faculty of Policy Studies at Chuo University in Japan.
I threw these responses out in less than half an hour. I seriously hope Prof. McNally does not teach basic logic. A shorter version of this has already been e-mailed to McNally:
*1. There is no forensic evidence whatsoever for the hoaxoco$t.
This is simply not true. If McNally (and other deniers) would define "forensic," we could move forward from there, but they never do. So the first stage in debating these "theses" would be to establish the truth or falsity of this first thesis. But we can't do that because McNally, like most deniers, won't define terms first.
*2. There logically cannot be any holyhoax eyewitnesses.
This is begging the question. We have yet to establish (1).
*3. All so-called holocaust evidence is merely hearsay and senile lies.
That can only apply to eyewitnesses, if even then. So we're back to (1)
*4. The hoaxoco$t affirmers jump grasshopper-like from refuted lies to
new lies awaiting refutation.
Can McNally provide a single example?
*5. The hoaxoco$t is world history`s filthiest blood libel.
How so? Wouldn't something like the Lincoln and Norwich blood libels be worse, considering they ended in violence against and mass deportatation of Jews?
*6. The Awshucks Labor Camp had more amenities than the USA WW2 camps for Japanese Americans.
A swimming pool used only by SS is not going to cut it, nor is a movie theater.
*7. Crematoria are never used anywhere to kill people. They are used to burn the bodies of people who are already dead. There is nothing ominous about crematoria.
There is something ominous about 52 crematoria muffles able to incinerate over 2,500 bodies per day. In a camp that could barely hold 200,000 people, it's a bit strange to be able to incinerate the entire camp population in less than three months, unless you're expecting mass deaths to occur.
*8. Awshucks and all labor camps had insecticidal gas chambers.
This proves or disproves nothing.
*9. Insecticidal gas chambers saved Jewish lives.
And they saved SS lives. Which do you think were more important to the Nazis?
*10. There were no homicidal gas chambers anywhere in German occupied territory.
What about at Auschwitz, Belzec, Chelmno, Treblinka, Majdanek, and Sobibor?
*11. Faurisson`s Challenge [Draw me a homicidal gas chamber!] must be met. Holocaustomaniacs must finally put up or shut up!
Why? What special right does Faurisson have to have his demands met that others
do not? We're talking about a man who, for years, asked for "just one proof" of gas chambers, and when Jean-Claude Pressac published a whole book of proofs, and Faurisson still won't shut up.
*12. There were no 6,000,000 jooz to be killed.
Sure there were. The Wannsee Protokol has that nearly that many in Poland and Ukraine alone.
*13. During WW2 there was a war going on. During wars people die and get killed.
Again, this proves or disproves nothing.
*14. If Hiroshima deaths were not murders, neither were Auschwitz deaths.
Straw man alert! Hiroshima was murder.
*15. Hiroshima and Nagasaki were real holocausts [killing by burning].
OK, so let's just call the Holocaust the Shoah instead.
*16. The only real holocaust in Germany was against Germans in their firebombed cities.
That emanates only from your limited definition of "Holocaust."
*17. The worst war criminals [1941-1945] were the American Air Farce fire bombing squadrons.
All sides in the war committed crimes. Both Americans and Japanese did in the Pacific Theater, and we know the Soviets did. The British did most of the bombing of Dresden. But does that exculpate the Nazis? No, it doesn't.
*18. There is better and more proof for the Trojan War than for the holyhoax.
There is no proof at all for the Trojan War, or even Troy.
*19. Belief in the hoaxoco$t is epistemologically similar to belief in witches.
Did the perpetrators of torture during the witch trials confess to engaging in torture? Because if they didn't, then you're wrong.
*20. Belief in the hoaxoco#t is morally much worse than belief in witches.
Based in whose moral calculus? Yours?
21. G, Rudolf`s Lectures on the Holocaust is the indispensable vademecum for students of the holocaust.
Perhaps then you can explain why Mr. Irving withdrew Mr. Rudolf's affidavit from evidence?
*22. The constant changes in the holyhoax fable are due to revisionist pressure and not to any jooish honesty.
This is a classic post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy.
*23. Jooz have abandoned the filthy "soap made from Jews" blood libel.
No, historians have abandoned it.
24. The whole hollowcause story is exactly like the filthy "soap made from Jews" lie.
This shows an utter failure to show causation.
*25. Only jooish obstinacy, greed, and mendacity maintain the Hoaxocost Lie.
And all that inconvenient evidence. Back to (1).
26. The Awshucks Labor Camp was much safer than the German cities being bombed.
Again, begging the question.
27. Giving false testimony must be a criminal and tort offense. ["Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor!"]
So shall we punish sixty-nine SS witnesses for bearing false witness against themselves?
*28. In colloquial English and bureaucratic German, the phrase "Auschwitz Lie" has exactly opposite meanings.
This is a completely irrelevant observation.
*29. If the Auschwitz Lie collapses, the hoaxoco$t collapses.
This is false dilemma.
*30. The holyhoax is the Achilles heel of Jew Power over Gentiles.
Again, begging the question.
*31. If the hoaxoco$t collapses, Jew Power collapses.
*32. Nazis wanted to deport Jooz to somewhere.
Wow, we agree!
*33. Zionists wanted jooz to be deported to somewhere.
Again, we agree.
*34. Nazis and Zionists cooperated to save jooz by getting them out of the war zone to Palestine.
It couldn't have happened that way. Germany never controlled the Mediterranean. As such, the British Navy never lost its ability to enforce its white papers on Palestine that restricted and later outlawed immigration.
*35. Russia and Western Europe have different railroad width gauges.
*36. The Bergen-Belch-Burp Camp and several other camps were located at
the railroad width gauge difference line. They were all transit camps and
not death camps.
This is a faulty syllogism. You cannot conclude your final sentence from your penultimate premise.
*37. If it is morally acceptable for Jews to deport Palestinians from
their homeland, it was morally acceptable for Germans to deport Jews from a
country not their homeland. This is called Torah tit-for-tat.
Another straw man.
*38. Deholyhoaxotoxification is urgently needed.
I don't even understand what that means.
*39. Both the Nurnberg Show Trials and Stalin`s Show Trials used lots of
torture to get confessions.
Who was tortured at Nuremberg?
*40. The Nurnberg Show Trials were far worse than Stalin`s Show Trials
because a whole people was condemned in perpetuity at Nurnberg.
Only if one believes that all Germans were Nazis. Do you?
*41. An international commission must study the forensic aspects of the
holocaust accusations of murder. This commission cannot include any
Jews, Christians, or citizens of HOGs [Holocaust Occupied Governments].
So who will do it? Muslims? Buddhists? Avowed atheists from Samoa?
*42. Finkelstein`s witty and informative The Holocaust Industry does not
even touch on the holocaust as such.
*43. Jooz lie and then get angry when people do not believe their lies.
As do all people, but I question the relevance of this statement. And I seriously question whether all Jews lie, if that is your suggestion.
*44. The absolutely biggest jooish lie is the hoaxoco$t.
And again, begging the question.
*45. The holyhoax fable is nothing but jooish hate speech.
*46. Jooish anti-Gentile lies are a clever defense tactic.
Defense against what?
*47. Gentiles get so overwhelmed by jooish lies that they do not see that jooz are committing the very crimes they accuse Gentiles of.
Where are "Jooz" using gas chambers?
*48. Gentiles will stop telling truths about jooz when jooz stop telling lies about Gentiles.
What truths are being told about Jews that we would want stopped?
*49. Germans must institute a class action lawsuit against the holocaust jet-set plutocrats.
That'll go over big.
*50. The hoaxoco$tofried European Union should be dissolved back into its member states.
I object to this "thesis" on the grounds of relevance.
*51. Holocaust affirmers should be incarcerated.
This would be violation of First Amendment and Article 19 of the U.N. charter.
*52. World Jewry has to pay back all money extorted via the Auschwitz Lie.
Back to our good old friend begging the question.
*53. The once proud German people have become cowards enslaved by the
And again: Begging the question.
*54. Germany is now a HOG [Holocaust Obsessed Government].
I don't see how. They seem to have moved past it.
*55. The Hoaxoco$t is the worse plague facing humanity today.
AIDS kills millions yearly. How many die at the hands of the Holocaust?
*56. All UN member states should institute an anti-Holocaust loyalty
oath for their citizens. No holocaust affirmer can be trusted.
This is McCarthyism at best and fascism at worst.
*57. The holyhoaxofried UN itself should be disbanded.
Would that be before or after your McCarthyite "loyalty oath"?
*58. The holyhoax must be privatized, i.e. removed from public space.
Again, I object due to relevance.
*59. All hoaxoco$t museums, libraries, and stink tanks must be closed.
*60. Alley the Weasel told significant lies to get his UAssA citizenship.
Please name them or retract this ad hominem.
*61. Alley the Weasel is a schmaltzy vicious hate-mongering racist liar.
*62. Alley the Weasel, history`s filthiest libeler, should be deported
back to the JewsOnlyState whence he came. He did not come to the USA as a
homeless refugee but as a speaker and spreader of anti-Gentile hatred.
Wiesel never lived in Israel. Unless you mean that France, from which Wiesel emigrated to the U.S., is a "JewsOnlyState."
*63. The Holocaust industry causes infinitely more harm than the tobacco
industry. Public health warnings should be put on anything published by
Tobacco kills 500,000 Americans per year. Again, as per (55), it is your job to prove what you allege.
*64. The Hoaxoco$t is elite Jewry`s cash cow, golden calf, and prize
alibi for any and all of its crimes.
Perhaps, but again, what is the relevance?
*65. The holocaust fable has replaced Christ`s Crucifixion.
So history literally changed?
*66. The birth of Isrealhell has replaced Christ`s Resurrection.
*67. Holocaustianity has replaced Christianity.
So what organization does Benedict XVI run?
*68. The vast majority of the jooish sheeple are hoaxoco$t racists.
This is more ad hominem.
*69. Israel must continue to exist but within the 1948 UN mandated borders.
OK, but I again object due to relevance.
*70. Israel can continue to serve as an open-air mental hospital for incorrigible racists. Where could Izzies go?
This is again ad hominem.
*71. There cannot be any ¡Èone state solution¡É forcing Palestinians to live with racist joos.
*72. The apart-hate JewState must get rid of its worse than Nazi race laws.
Could Jews in Germany vote after 1935?
*73. Israel sees the UAssA as its chief near-term enemy.
What proof is there of this assertion?
*74. Israel destroys the UAssA through its fifth column of traitors high
in the American government. Israel blackmails the JewAssA into wars fought
for the JewState and these wars are bleeding America to death.
*75. Unrepentant racist Jews must be helped to emigrate to the
demilitarized JewState or be put back into a new ghetto.
Got yourself a little Madagascar plan, do you?
*76. Jewdayism is not any kind of a religion but merely a racist
How is Judaism racist? Give examples.
*77. Zio-Judyism must be privatized back into the synagogues and mental
This is self-contradiction. You said above that Israel should continue to exist.
*78. Zio-Judaism is a Tallmud teaching of anti-Gentile hatred.
The Talmud is specifically against Zionism.
*79. Aliyah Zionism teaches that all jooz should emigrate to Izzie. Actually a great idea!
This is actually a terrible idea. Fourteen million Jews in a space the size of Delaware is a invitation to a nuclear attack by people like you.
*80. Non-aliyah Zionism teaches that jooz should support the JewsOnlyState by acting as a fifth column of traitors in the various cattle-goyim states. Not a good idea!
Any proof for this whopper? Of course not.
*81. Zionism must be recognized as [not even] a racism.
Once again, the relevance here cannot be established?
*82. Any Gentile racism is on a higher moral level than Zionism.
*83. Semitism [Jewish Supremacy] teaches that a joo elite should use deceit to dominate cattle goyim nations. Semitists principally use the Auschwitz Club to control the goyim
Again, there is no proof offered here -- just assertions.
*84. Anti-Semitists [not anti-Semites] are urgently needed to fight Semitism [jooish supremacy].
You say potato.
*85. The "Clash of Civilizations" is just a joo scam used to cause wars against and among all humans.
Proof? Relevance? Either? Both?
*86. Jewry is defeating the West [both Black and White] with the hoaxoco$t lie. Jewry is simultaneously waging an anti-Islamic war using Gentile stooges to fight and die for Isrealhell.
Where is war being waged against Islam per se?
*87. Jewry`s multi-front wars are very risky for Mr. Joo because some cattle goyim might wake up.
Which wars are we speaking of?
*88. The German [Hitler] Revolution was very democratic. The French and Russian Revolutions were very undemocratic.
Can we see a demonstration of any relevance whatsoever?
*89. Elite Jewry started WW2 in 1933 by unilaterally declaring war on Germany.
So why did it take Germany six years to retaliate? This is beyond senseless. An economic boycott by a stateless people cannot be and is not an act of war.
*90. Jewism is the residual racism uniting the Solomon Sixpackers, i.e.
the hoi polloi of the jooish sheeple.
There is no proof offered. Again.
*91. The jooish contribution to Gentile societies is a net negative.
Look at a list of Nobel winners some time.
*92. An anti-Semitist [not auntie-Semenist] used to mean someone who hates Semitists. Now an anti-Semitist means someone whom Semitists hate.
You, again, say potato.
*93. A Zionist used to mean a Jew who wanted to send stupider Jews to Palestine. Now a Zionist is often a rich¡¡Jew who escapes from Israel and leaves the stupidest jooz holding the bag as the JewState implodes.
This is perhaps true, but where is the freaking relevance?
*94. The War on Terrorism [actually a War on Common Sense] is a joo- inspired scheme to get stupid Whites and Christians to kill innocent Arabs and Muslims.
Is there any proof of Jewish contrivance? Or any demonstration of relevance?
*95. Delendae sunt Judaea atque holyhoaxotoxia! [Israel and the hoaxoco$t must be destroyed.
And we end with another self-contradiction.
Can you respond to this without ad hominem? I'll bet $100 you can't.