I LOVE how one of their arguments is that the Franke-Grischke report is "obscure" and that "not even mainstream Holocaust historians use it".
I mean, wow. This is coming from the mouths of the same people who build mountains of inphographics, memes and, well, arguments based ton tiny little expets from obscure tabloids and unknown booklings that literally nobody knows about, exept the deniers who bring them up (i.e.: Auschwiz rollercoaster, masturbation machines and electric floors, Moshe Peer's classic).
Nothing is too obscure when it is convinient for them.
You have done multiple excellent debunkings of the Stalin apologist Grover Furr on Katyn and the Moscow Trials. Would you mind doing a post on some of his other absurdities, such as his defence of Stalin's deportations or of his claims that the Soviet invasion of Poland in 1939 wasn't an invasion? They can be found here:
Anyone defending Stalin's ethnic cleansings is automatically a racist, so there's nothing else to say, really.
As for the second, Nazi Germany and USSR had a friendship treaty, which made them allies in a significant sense, and obviously a state doesn't simply cease to exist due to a short-term absence of a government, a government crossing a border doesn't mean absence of the government, and USSR invaded Poland before the Polish government left it, so USSR invaded the Polish state according to a plan they worked out with their Nazi allies.
Let's just look at the beginning of his screed: "It is now admitted that no more than 70,000 died at Majdanek"
The official museum estimate is 78,000.
"Eric Hunt's new film has exposed Caroline Sturdy Colls' attempt to prove the Majdanek shower rooms were occult gas chambers as laughable. Especially with the CO2 tanks in the back room that supposedly pumped out CO."
The CO2 cylinders are not claimed to have been there originally, we have photos of the original CO cylinders.
"Does anyone also remember also how the allied powers lowered one of the ceilings in Dachau to claim it was a gas chamber"
Nobody remembers this since this never happened.
"and now it is admitted that it was not a gas chamber ever in Dachau?"
Nothing like that has ever been "admitted" at Dachau, another lie.
Thank you for answer. I'm sorry to interrupt, but can you say about second part? I know, that you are busy. That about Werd... I saw, that he misrepresented words from Nessie.
Okay. I understand you. 'The official museum estimate is 78,000.' Here? https://web.archive.org/web/20131004213633/http://en.auschwitz.org/m/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=44&Itemid=8
Why does anyone still quote Eric Hunt? He defected and acknowledged that the Holocaust happened, and that Colls' forensic findings were corroborated by both the Poles and Grave Robbers thru the decades?
Mikey has since posted a number of Holocaust "Fact-Checking" (Denial) videos onto the right stuff BitChute channel. Do you have any interest in responding to them?
I LOVE how one of their arguments is that the Franke-Grischke report is "obscure" and that "not even mainstream Holocaust historians use it".
ReplyDeleteI mean, wow. This is coming from the mouths of the same people who build mountains of inphographics, memes and, well, arguments based ton tiny little expets from obscure tabloids and unknown booklings that literally nobody knows about, exept the deniers who bring them up (i.e.: Auschwiz rollercoaster, masturbation machines and electric floors, Moshe Peer's classic).
Nothing is too obscure when it is convinient for them.
Hello Sergey,
ReplyDeleteYou have done multiple excellent debunkings of the Stalin apologist Grover Furr on Katyn and the Moscow Trials. Would you mind doing a post on some of his other absurdities, such as his defence of Stalin's deportations or of his claims that the Soviet invasion of Poland in 1939 wasn't an invasion? They can be found here:
https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~furrg/deportations_GT1110_eng.pdf
https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~furrg/research/mlg09/did_ussr_invade_poland.html
Anyone defending Stalin's ethnic cleansings is automatically a racist, so there's nothing else to say, really.
DeleteAs for the second, Nazi Germany and USSR had a friendship treaty, which made them allies in a significant sense, and obviously a state doesn't simply cease to exist due to a short-term absence of a government, a government crossing a border doesn't mean absence of the government, and USSR invaded Poland before the Polish government left it, so USSR invaded the Polish state according to a plan they worked out with their Nazi allies.
Escuss me, but can we say about the post from Werd? Maybe, we can answer? I can not trust him. https://rodoh.info/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=2063
ReplyDeleteI am Russian, but I don't really know English.
Delete"Maybe, we can answer?"
DeleteI mean ""Can you answer?"
Werd is a well-known pathological liar.
DeleteLet's just look at the beginning of his screed: "It is now admitted that no more than 70,000 died at Majdanek"
The official museum estimate is 78,000.
"Eric Hunt's new film has exposed Caroline Sturdy Colls' attempt to prove the Majdanek shower rooms were occult gas chambers as laughable. Especially with the CO2 tanks in the back room that supposedly pumped out CO."
The CO2 cylinders are not claimed to have been there originally, we have photos of the original CO cylinders.
"Does anyone also remember also how the allied powers lowered one of the ceilings in Dachau to claim it was a gas chamber"
Nobody remembers this since this never happened.
"and now it is admitted that it was not a gas chamber ever in Dachau?"
Nothing like that has ever been "admitted" at Dachau, another lie.
There no need to go on, is there?
Thank you for answer. I'm sorry to interrupt, but can you say about second part? I know, that you are busy. That about Werd... I saw, that he misrepresented words from Nessie.
DeleteAnd first part... It did not impresse me.
DeleteI stopped reading after the first part, sorry.
DeleteOkay. I understand you.
Delete'The official museum estimate is 78,000.'
Here? https://web.archive.org/web/20131004213633/http://en.auschwitz.org/m/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=44&Itemid=8
Why does anyone still quote Eric Hunt? He defected and acknowledged that the Holocaust happened, and that Colls' forensic findings were corroborated by both the Poles and Grave Robbers thru the decades?
DeleteSorry, Mr. Nathan (if I'm not mistaken.), but what can you say about second part from Werd? I'm sorry to interrupt.
DeleteMikey has since posted a number of Holocaust "Fact-Checking" (Denial) videos onto the right stuff BitChute channel. Do you have any interest in responding to them?
ReplyDeleteEven other Deniers admit that BitChute is full of Strawmen that makes them look bad.
Delete