Wednesday, January 20, 2010

"The People Got Together And Look What Happened"

Author: Roberto Muehlenkamp
Joachim Neander's excellent article Irene Zisblatt, the "Diamond Girl" - Fact or Fiction? got this euphoric eulogy from CODOH poster "Carto's Cutlass Supreme" (who seems to be identical with our old friend "denierbud").

CCS refrained from posting the link to Dr. Neander's article, however.

Maybe he's concerned that his fellow posters, when reading the whole article, will painfully notice the difference between proper scholarship and "Revisionist" pseudo-scholarship.

Or discover that Dr. Neander, after citing "the most important researcher of all regarding this: Eric Hunt" (CCS), described how he used Hunt's document collection to reconstruct Mrs. Zisblatt's actual biography, which is nothing for "Revisionists" to be happy about:

Final conclusion

My research clearly shows that Irene Weisberg Zisblatt is not only a survivor of Auschwitz and the Holocaust, but that she, indeed, has an interesting and instructive story to tell. A story of endless humiliations and extreme suffering, but also of survival against all odds. It would be similar to those that hundreds of survivors can tell or have already told. It certainly would be less adventurous than that which she tells. But it would be in accordance with the historically established facts. Irene Weisberg Zisblatt should tell her story about survival at Auschwitz without exaggerations and implausibilities. It then would be a really true story, worth to be told and retold and to be listened to.

A denier's document collection met a scholar who knew how to use it, and look what happened.


Wahrheit said...

Hey Roberto,

I saw CCS's thread several hours ago, and it did indeed have a link to Dr. Neander's article. As the Moderator has made an appearance after the fact, I suspect that an "edit" was made to the original post, but not by CCS...

Sergey Romanov said...

Heh, at last some kudos to CCCCS, if he indeed posted the link. IT didn't seem, however, that there was a ban on HC blog at CODOH until now.

BTW, the "5 diamond" is just a hypothesis. Certain later developments (which I will not reveal now) call it into question.